Review Gates

Gate 1 — Mission completeness

• Goal is clear.
• Context files are ordered.
• Constraints and non-goals are explicit.
• Expected outputs are named.
• Verification requirements exist.

Gate 2 — Runtime compatibility

• Adapter supports required capabilities.
• Sandbox backend is available.
• Required skills can be loaded or approximated.

Gate 3 — Spec compliance

• Output satisfies linked issue/spec/mission criteria.
• Any deviations are documented.

Gate 4 — Quality

• Changes are coherent, minimal, and maintainable.
• Docs are navigable and understandable.
• Code, when present, follows project conventions.

Gate 5 — Security/sandbox

• No unexpected writes outside sandbox.
• No secrets stored in artifacts.
• Risky commands/actions are documented.

Gate 6 — Human promotion approval

• Human reviewer approves selected changes for canonical state.
• Promotion record is written.